Landmark victory: Hermes secures permanent ban on ‘MetaBirkin’ NFT sales in US lawsuit

TL;DR Breakdown

  • On Friday, a federal judge in Manhattan sided with Hermes and temporarily halted the sale of “MetaBirkin” non-fungible tokens by artist Mason Rothschild after a jury found that the tokens infringed on the French luxury brand’s trademark rights in its signature Birkin bag in the U.S.
  • Rothschild (real name Sonny Estival) defended his art by arguing that it was an absurdist statement on luxury items and hence protected by the 1st Amendment.
  • According to Rothschild in court, Hermes’ request was “far beyond what is appropriate in a case, like this one, that involves artistic expression.” 

Description

On Friday, a federal judge in Manhattan accepted Hermes’ plea to permanently halt artist Mason Rothschild’s sales of “MetaBirkin” non-fungible tokens after a jury found that they infringed upon the French luxury brand’s trademark rights in its well-known Birkin handbags. Federal judge injuncts MetaBirkin NFT sales According to US District Judge Jed Rakoff, the permanent … Read more

On Friday, a federal judge in Manhattan accepted Hermes’ plea to permanently halt artist Mason Rothschild’s sales of “MetaBirkin” non-fungible tokens after a jury found that they infringed upon the French luxury brand’s trademark rights in its well-known Birkin handbags.

Federal judge injuncts MetaBirkin NFT sales

According to US District Judge Jed Rakoff, the permanent injunction was necessary because Rothschild’s ongoing promotion of the NFTs would probably confuse consumers and irrevocably injure the company.

Rothschild asked Rakoff to overturn the decision or order a new trial, but he refused.

According to Rakoff, the defendant’s strategy’s entire goal was to trick consumers into thinking that Hermes was promoting the lucrative MetaBirkins NFTs by using variations on Hermes’ trademarks. 

As per the court, nothing in the First Amendment shields him from responsibility for such a scheme.

Representatives of Hermes and Rothschild did not immediately respond to requests for comments regarding the decision. 

The ‘MetaBirkin’ debate and NFTs’ ascent

Tokens that can’t be exchanged with anybody else are called non-fungible tokens (NFTs), and they’re utilized on blockchains to prove ownership of digital artwork. Hermes sued Rothschild because his MetaBirkins NFTs mocked the luxury brand’s Birkin bags by depicting them with fake fur in bright colours. 

On blockchain networks, NFTs are distinctive tokens that are frequently used to confirm ownership of digital art. Hermes filed a lawsuit against Rothschild last year over his MetaBirkins, 100 NFTs linked to pictures of the coveted Birkin handbags from the high-end brand covered in vibrant fur.

Hermes referred to Rothschild as a “digital speculator” and the NFTs as a “get rich quick” scheme that violated the rights to its “Birkin” trademark and gave a false impression that the fashion house supported the tokens.

Hermes said that the NFTs made it look like they endorsed the products when they didn’t. On the other hand, Rothschild maintained that his creations were an expression of free speech because they were absurdist statements about luxury goods.

Rothschild, whose real name is Sonny Estival, defended his works by claiming they were absurdist statements on luxury goods. This defence was supported by the First Amendment of the United States Constitution, which shields work that makes artistically relevant use of trademarks without intentionally misleading consumers from liability in trademark infringement lawsuits. 

In February, the jury awarded Hermes $133,000 in damages. In a March filing, Hermes claimed that Rothschild kept selling his NFTs even after the verdict. It pleaded with the court to order him to stop and hand over any remaining tokens and profits he had made.

According to Rothschild in court, Hermes’ request was “far beyond what is appropriate in a case, like this one, that involves artistic expression.” 

Rakoff largely granted Hermes’ request but chose not to direct Rothschild to transfer the tokens due to an “abundance of caution” regarding First Amendment issues. 

Implications for the luxury market and the art market

The luxury goods industry, the art market, and the growth of NFTs will all be profoundly impacted by the outcome of the Hermes v. ‘MetaBirkin’ NFT case. This emphasizes the importance of IP protection in the digital age and makes it crystal clear that luxury brands will not tolerate the unauthorized use of their trademarked designs. This major win will aid in enforcing trademarks and protecting authentic products from counterfeit NFTs in the digital sphere for other luxury brands.

Hermes’ crushing victory in the ‘MetaBirkin’ NFT lawsuit marks a watershed moment in the ongoing struggle to protect intellectual property rights in the burgeoning field of NFTs. By successfully suing for a permanent injunction to prevent the distribution of the infringing digital assets, Hermes has proven itself to be a staunch protector of the quality and exclusivity of its name.

Those engaging in the illegal reproduction of luxury goods in the digital space should take this decision as a wake-up call, as the court has reaffirmed the importance of trademark rights and opened the door for future legal battles over the protection of luxury brands in the age of NFTs.

Disclaimer. The information provided is not trading advice. Cryptopolitan.com holds no liability for any investments made based on the information provided on this page. We strongly recommend independent research and/or consultation with a qualified professional before making any investment decision.

文章来源于互联网:Landmark victory: Hermes secures permanent ban on ‘MetaBirkin’ NFT sales in US lawsuit

Disclaimers:

1. You are solely responsible for your investment decisions and this info is not liable for any losses you may incur.

2. The copyright of this article belongs to the writer, it represents the writer's opinions only, not represents the site's ones. Not financial advice.

Previous 2023年6月26日 18:20
Next 2023年6月26日 20:02

Related articles

  • Legal setbacks and lawsuit shake FTX as founder’s defense strategy is thwarted

    TL;DR Breakdown FTX co-founder denied access to documents from Fenwick & West in federal fraud case defense. FTX files lawsuit to reclaim over $700 million from investment firms. Description Sam Bankman-Fried has been denied his request to obtain documents from Silicon Valley law firm Fenwick & West LLP as part of his defense strategy in his federal fraud case, according to a court order from Friday. Bankman-Fried had sought these documents to support his claim that he relied on legal advice while engaging in … Read more Sam Bankman-Fried has been denied his request to obtain documents from Silicon Valley law firm Fenwick & West LLP as part of his defense strategy in his federal fraud case, according to a court order from Friday. Bankman-Fried had sought these documents to support his claim that he relied on legal advice while engaging in the activities for which he is currently facing prosecution. Bankman-Fried’s legal team approached U.S. District Judge Lewis Kaplan, who oversees the case, urging the prosecution to hand over the documents obtained from Fenwick & West or to allow…

    Article 2023年6月26日
  • Ethereum left in Bitcoin’s dust as SEC lingers

    TL;DR Breakdown Ethereum’s performance is being affected by regulatory uncertainties, making it lag behind Bitcoin. The SEC is yet to decide if Ether will be classified as an unregistered security, which can complicate its trading process. Bitcoin, treated as a commodity, has seen an increase in value due to investor flight from regulatory risk and anticipation of new Bitcoin exchange-traded funds. Description As the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) casts a vigilant gaze over the evolving world of cryptocurrency, the regulatory future of Ethereum, the second-largest digital currency, hangs in balance. Analysts indicate this uncertainty is hindering Ether’s progress, causing it to lag behind the market leader, Bitcoin. The crux of the regulatory ambiguity centers around … Read more As the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) casts a vigilant gaze over the evolving world of cryptocurrency, the regulatory future of Ethereum, the second-largest digital currency, hangs in balance. Analysts indicate this uncertainty is hindering Ether’s progress, causing it to lag behind the market leader, Bitcoin. The crux of the regulatory ambiguity centers around whether the SEC will classify…

    Article 2023年6月29日
  • CFTC takes decisive action against leading DeFi protocols

    TL;DR Breakdown The CFTC penalizes Opyn, ZeroEx, and Deridex for failing to register their derivatives trading offerings and other regulatory oversights. The action emphasizes the importance of DeFi platforms operating within legal boundaries, even as the sector continues to innovate and evolve. Description In a significant move, the United States Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) has taken regulatory action against three prominent decentralized finance (DeFi) protocols. The entities in question, Opyn, ZeroEx, and Deridex, have been penalized for allegedly failing to register their derivatives trading offerings. This decision underscores the regulatory body’s commitment to ensuring that DeFi platforms … Read more In a significant move, the United States Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) has taken regulatory action against three prominent decentralized finance (DeFi) protocols. The entities in question, Opyn, ZeroEx, and Deridex, have been penalized for allegedly failing to register their derivatives trading offerings. This decision underscores the regulatory body’s commitment to ensuring that DeFi platforms operate within the confines of the law. Unregistered offerings and violations The CFTC’s announcement on September 8 revealed that it had issued orders against…

    Article 2023年9月8日
  • Kenya urges Africa to dump the US dollar

    TL;DR Breakdown Kenya’s President, William Ruto, urges Africa to move away from using the U.S. dollar in intra-continental trade. Ruto champions the Pan-African Payment and Settlement System, facilitating trade in local currencies. Capital control measures often lead to economic drawbacks, deterring investors. Making a compelling case to free Africa’s economic prospects from the influence of the U.S. dollar, Kenya’s President William Ruto recently pressed the continent to embrace a new financial future. Advocating for a pivot in the African trading system, Ruto emphasized the need for continental economic self-reliance. Kenya takes the lead in advocating for Pan-African economic autonomy Trade practices within Africa have long been subject to the supremacy of the U.S. dollar. Whether it’s Kenyan merchants doing business with Djibouti or other intra-continental transactions, the necessity for the U.S. currency often becomes an unavoidable obstacle. However, Kenya’s leadership envisions a future where the continent’s business is settled in local currencies through the African Export-Import Bank (AfriEximBank). Arguing that the presence of the U.S. dollar in the trade equation between two African countries doesn’t add up, Ruto made a…

    Article 2023年6月18日
  • EDX Markets reportedly drops Paxos as custodian, in talks with Anchorage Digital for new partnership

    TL;DR Breakdown EDX Markets, a newly launched crypto exchange, is in final talks with Anchorage Digital to replace Paxos as its custodial partner. The shift to Anchorage Digital aligns with EDX’s non-custodial model and aims to avoid conflicts of interest. Paxos faced regulatory challenges and the expiration of its preliminary conditional approval for a US bank charter, prompting EDX’s search for a new custodial partner. Description New York-based cryptocurrency exchange, EDX Markets, has reportedly made a significant shift in custody arrangements, dropping its previous partnership with Paxos and entering final negotiations with Anchorage Digital for a new collaboration. The earlier pact with Paxos, announced in October, would have directed EDX’s clients to Paxos for the custody of their digital assets while … Read more New York-based cryptocurrency exchange, EDX Markets, has reportedly made a significant shift in custody arrangements, dropping its previous partnership with Paxos and entering final negotiations with Anchorage Digital for a new collaboration. The earlier pact with Paxos, announced in October, would have directed EDX’s clients to Paxos for the custody of their digital assets while allowing…

    Article 2023年6月30日
TOP